Heifer International is an organization committed to addressing global hunger. The Heifer strategy is to provide livestock and training for the nutrition and livelihood of a family in need, with the understanding that the family will pass on one of its animal's offspring to another deserving household. The Heifer organization, according to its website services 125 countries and has reached out to 12 million families since its inception in 1944.
The organization draws sharp criticism from individuals and groups concerned about animal cruelty, specifically those who promote vegetarianism and veganism. The discourse of criticism against Heifer International is distinctive because it must advance beyond the usual lines of attack against meat/dairy consumption as a diet choice and address Heifer's moral commitment to serve the global poor. A wesbite called all-creatures.org features a collection of posts that condemn the Heifer Project as a misguided approach to solving global hunger.
Arguments that attack Heifer's approach need to establish sympathy for the issue of global hunger even as they reproach the use of animals to solve this problem. As one of the posts on all-creatures.org recognizes, those who oppose Heifer's mission may well be criticized for loving animals more than people. Therefore activists against animal cruelty attempt to discredit Heifer's strategy of helping the hungry poor, by arguing that this practice is more harmful than beneficial to the populations it claims to serve.
One of the specific anti-Heifer claims is that meat consumption actually contributes to gloabl hunger by usurping land that could be used to grow plant food for humans and dedicating it instead to the production of fodder for animals. George Monibot in a 2002 article entitled, "Why vegans were right all along" argues that the solution to global famine depends on a reduction in meat consumption by the wealthy. While Monibot does not address the Heifer Project specifically, his argument is echoed by those who oppose Heifer International. According to Monibot's article, livestock consume half the global supply of grain and he warns that we will soon be forced to confront an ethical choice to cultivate the world's arable land for either people or animals.
The clash between the reasoning that supports Heifer's mission and the reasoning provided in counter-Heifer discourse, functions on the basis of a rhetorical distinction identified by Perelman and Olbrechts-Tyteca -namely the contrast between consequences to a fact and means to an end. According to these argument theorists, rhetors may choose to present a causal link either as a case of act-consequence or a case of means-end. Each formulation serves to emphasize and diminish a different term within the concept-pair. That is, different assertions are made by either emphasing the "singleness of the act against the plurality of its consequences" or emphasizing the "singleness of the end against the multiplicity of the means." (p. 271, The New Rhetoric).
What is common to both the Heifer mission and anti-Heifer discourse is a concern for addressing global hunger. The Heifer mission frames the solution to global hunger as an end. The choice of animals to achieve this goal is not particularly significant to the Heifer argument. There is no rhetorical effort to justify the use of animals over other alternatives. The history section on the Heifer website refers to the organization as the legacy of a Midwest farmer. The choice of animals as gift to the hungry was simply motivated by the founder's own occupation.
On the other hand, the anti-Heifer argument frames the Heifer mission as an act-consequence pair. The act is Heifer's service to the world's hungry. But unlike Heifer's own mission which casts this service as a means to an end, anti-Heifer advocates focus on the unintended consequences of the Heifer Project. They succeed in drawing more attention to the choice of animals as a solution because they extend the consequences of Heifer's service beyond feeding the poor and force us to take into account the impact that increased meat consumption will have, on our ability to produce grain for human consumption.
Thought for Food
A commentary on argument in food politics.
Tuesday, November 30, 2010
Sunday, November 28, 2010
Ideology and argumentative discourse - the role of the ideograph
I came across an interesting Newsweek essay entitled "Divided We Eat", that articulates my growing frustration with grocery shopping. I have been known to spend a couple of happy hours at a stretch in a grocery store. I especially enjoy browsing the aisles of specialty stores like the East Coast chain -Wegmans. I did not really consider the luxury of these experiences, until I moved to a less wealthy Midwest community that didn't offer high-end grocery store options. Now that I live in Milwaukee, close to a Whole Foods location, I am battling another obstacle. Having traded a full-time job for graduate school, I simply cannot afford to shop at a store like Whole Foods. What's worse, is that I have a hard time maintaining my resolution to consume more fruits and vegetables, because these items eat into my food budget so much more than processed food, even when I buy them at the more reasonable Pick n Save grocery chain.
Lisa Miller in the article, "Divided We Eat" advances the claim that food consumption has become the new marker of social class. Food has become fashion. She identifies the food snob, the health nut, and the locavore as ideal types that emerge in discourse about healthy eating. What's missing from this discourse however, is a recognition that ideal of healthy eating is simply out of reach for many with limited financial means. Miller cites Adam Drewnowski, epidemiologist at the University of Washington, who exposes a case of economic elitism in the practice of advocating the typical healthy diet of fruits, vegetables, lean meats, fish and grains; since these foods are unaffordable for the poorest Americans.
Drewnoski's observation echoes a discursive exchange I witnessed a few weeks ago. Nationally acclaimed locavore advocate Michael Pollan delivered a lecture at our campus, in which he argued strongly against eating processed foods. During the subsequent question-answer session, Pollan was asked by a college student what she could do to follow his advice on a meager food budget. Pollan didn't have much to say, except to agree that healthy food was expensive, but that she could try cooking rather than eating ready foods, for a somewhat cheaper, healthier alternative.
My own frustrations with grocery shopping and Pollan's response to the college student became crystallized as a serious problem in the arguments presented by Miller's article. I now see <healthy eating> as a possible ideograph in McGee's sense - that is a constellation of meanings that function as warrants for beliefs and behavior. The discourse of and around healthy eating is growing wider and louder. It is imposed as an ideal across populations (wealthy and not). For instance, Miller mentions a proposed New York City ban on the use of food-stamps to buy soda. Few of us can escape the shame of surviving on fast-food and snack-food diets. But the castigatory ideograph of <healthy eating> hides a significant, material imbalance. I recognize now that the shame of an unhealthy diet may be unjustifiably conferred on those who cannot afford to eat healthy.
A key characteristic of the ideograph is its abstract nature, allowing it to capture multiple connotations that approach an ideology. Although <healthy eating> is traditionally defined in terms of the food pyramid, or key nutritional components, health food advocates like Pollan are now redefining what it means to eat healthy. Pollan's lecture that I mentioned above, critiqued the obssessive calorie and nutrient regulations of current healthy diet practices and advocated instead that we return food from the realm of the laboratory to the realm of relationships - that is, to see food as something we share with others and as something through which we enact a relationship to the rest of the natural world.
Regardless of how it is defined, I believe an ideograph such as <healthy eating> while it serves to reflect and constitute an ideology, can simultaneously obscure material injustices that prevent some people from participating in that ideology. Blind to its partiality, proponents of the ideograph nevertheless use it punitively to shame those who cannot participate.
Lisa Miller in the article, "Divided We Eat" advances the claim that food consumption has become the new marker of social class. Food has become fashion. She identifies the food snob, the health nut, and the locavore as ideal types that emerge in discourse about healthy eating. What's missing from this discourse however, is a recognition that ideal of healthy eating is simply out of reach for many with limited financial means. Miller cites Adam Drewnowski, epidemiologist at the University of Washington, who exposes a case of economic elitism in the practice of advocating the typical healthy diet of fruits, vegetables, lean meats, fish and grains; since these foods are unaffordable for the poorest Americans.
Drewnoski's observation echoes a discursive exchange I witnessed a few weeks ago. Nationally acclaimed locavore advocate Michael Pollan delivered a lecture at our campus, in which he argued strongly against eating processed foods. During the subsequent question-answer session, Pollan was asked by a college student what she could do to follow his advice on a meager food budget. Pollan didn't have much to say, except to agree that healthy food was expensive, but that she could try cooking rather than eating ready foods, for a somewhat cheaper, healthier alternative.
My own frustrations with grocery shopping and Pollan's response to the college student became crystallized as a serious problem in the arguments presented by Miller's article. I now see <healthy eating> as a possible ideograph in McGee's sense - that is a constellation of meanings that function as warrants for beliefs and behavior. The discourse of and around healthy eating is growing wider and louder. It is imposed as an ideal across populations (wealthy and not). For instance, Miller mentions a proposed New York City ban on the use of food-stamps to buy soda. Few of us can escape the shame of surviving on fast-food and snack-food diets. But the castigatory ideograph of <healthy eating> hides a significant, material imbalance. I recognize now that the shame of an unhealthy diet may be unjustifiably conferred on those who cannot afford to eat healthy.
A key characteristic of the ideograph is its abstract nature, allowing it to capture multiple connotations that approach an ideology. Although <healthy eating> is traditionally defined in terms of the food pyramid, or key nutritional components, health food advocates like Pollan are now redefining what it means to eat healthy. Pollan's lecture that I mentioned above, critiqued the obssessive calorie and nutrient regulations of current healthy diet practices and advocated instead that we return food from the realm of the laboratory to the realm of relationships - that is, to see food as something we share with others and as something through which we enact a relationship to the rest of the natural world.
Regardless of how it is defined, I believe an ideograph such as <healthy eating> while it serves to reflect and constitute an ideology, can simultaneously obscure material injustices that prevent some people from participating in that ideology. Blind to its partiality, proponents of the ideograph nevertheless use it punitively to shame those who cannot participate.
Tuesday, November 23, 2010
A picture speaks a thousand words: are any of them argumentative?
In this entry, I would like to explore the possibility of the visual argument. After all our readings this semester, I distill the process of argumentation into the advancement of claims supported by reasons. While this goal appears to be best served discursively, if the barebones of an argument are its claims and its evidence, then theoretically, this structure may be fleshed out in a visual format as well. The problem I suppose, is that we very rarely encounter the visual exclusively, without some verbal preview, accompaniment or conclusion. All the same, I would like to venture that our highly mediated social lives are experiencing an erosion in verbal messages and a corresponding ascendancy of the visual form.
Popular magazines are one example of the disproportionate role of images. It's been a while since I have read something like the Cosmopolitan from cover to cover; but from thumbing through recent issues, I don't know if reading such magazines is a possibility anymore. Images seem to have eaten up text. And the magazines feel frustratingly like children's picture books designed for an audience that is still learning to decipher the written word. I wonder if this trend caters to the shorter attention spans we are developing due to the mediated nature of our everyday social lives. The extended verbal prose of snail mail letters has given way to email short-hand and even more cryptic text messaging conventions. I suggest that the predominance of verbally lean messages creates a need for rhetors to condense arguments into forms that will speak the most in the least amount of time. Images rise to the occasion.
In keeping with my focus on food politics, I examine the role of the visual in the wesbite http://www.nofoiegras.org/, which protests the consumption of foie gras (fattened duck liver). The supporting claim is that foie gras production is cruel to the birds. I would like to contrast two images on the wesbite, in order to distinguish the dual roles that images may perform in persuasive appeals - namely, a more peripheral, enhancement function and a more direct, argumentative function. On the homepage, we see the site's banner which incorporates the black silhouette of a duck, enveloped in a white circle. A tiny red heart makes a striking contrast against the duck's black body. The drawing is iconic - it resembles the vulnerable bird. The peaceful white circle that wraps around the bird and its little red heart are invitations to consider it as a lovable, living creature rather than as simply a source for gourmet cuisine. But I would say this image doesn't argue. Rather, it augments, at a subconscious level the rhetorical message of the website.
On the other hand, the website's link to Photos and Videos takes us to a page with considerably less verbal text than we see on the homepage. In addition to a few video links, the page contains a series of images that are simply labelled Foie Gras Production. The pictures elicit reactions of disgust. Each focuses either on rows of tightly packed ducks in metal cages or close-ups of the birds covered in a yellowish, sloppy substance that we assume to be the food they are force-fed. One image shows a dumpster, filled with birds that appear dead. At first, the images stood alone. Only later as I moved my cursor over the series of photographs, did I realize there were accompanying notes to each of them. Since my initial engagement with the photographs occurred in the absence of explanatory text, I thought of the possibility for these images to function alone as arguments.
Even without immediate verbal context, a general knowledge of poultry farming practices would be sufficient for a viewer to realize that the pictures condemn the particular treatment of the ducks that they display. Therefore the pictures advance a claim. Further, the reasons for the condemnation are embedded in the injury, neglect and lack of cleanliness that are captured in the images. In this instance, I believe the visual accomplishes the role of the argument. Although, it's primary line of attack is emotional - that is, the photos are designed to evoke disgust, pity, and anger - I propose that the emotion arises out of a cognitive recognition of the argumentative elements - namely, the evidence supporting the claim. In fact, at this point, I am even prompted to suggest, that most argument works eventually in an emotional realm, whether that emotion be anger against insjustice, fear of an outcome, compassion for another or even the satisfaction of feeling righteously and logically convinced. Verbal arguments reach that emotional crux in a more circuitous and elaborate way. Visual arguments act upon us more quickly. To be realistic, the role of visual arguments is limited by their very expeditiousness. They are restricted by the sheer amount of information they can convey. And therefore, I accept they are still adjunct to verbal messages.
Popular magazines are one example of the disproportionate role of images. It's been a while since I have read something like the Cosmopolitan from cover to cover; but from thumbing through recent issues, I don't know if reading such magazines is a possibility anymore. Images seem to have eaten up text. And the magazines feel frustratingly like children's picture books designed for an audience that is still learning to decipher the written word. I wonder if this trend caters to the shorter attention spans we are developing due to the mediated nature of our everyday social lives. The extended verbal prose of snail mail letters has given way to email short-hand and even more cryptic text messaging conventions. I suggest that the predominance of verbally lean messages creates a need for rhetors to condense arguments into forms that will speak the most in the least amount of time. Images rise to the occasion.
In keeping with my focus on food politics, I examine the role of the visual in the wesbite http://www.nofoiegras.org/, which protests the consumption of foie gras (fattened duck liver). The supporting claim is that foie gras production is cruel to the birds. I would like to contrast two images on the wesbite, in order to distinguish the dual roles that images may perform in persuasive appeals - namely, a more peripheral, enhancement function and a more direct, argumentative function. On the homepage, we see the site's banner which incorporates the black silhouette of a duck, enveloped in a white circle. A tiny red heart makes a striking contrast against the duck's black body. The drawing is iconic - it resembles the vulnerable bird. The peaceful white circle that wraps around the bird and its little red heart are invitations to consider it as a lovable, living creature rather than as simply a source for gourmet cuisine. But I would say this image doesn't argue. Rather, it augments, at a subconscious level the rhetorical message of the website.
On the other hand, the website's link to Photos and Videos takes us to a page with considerably less verbal text than we see on the homepage. In addition to a few video links, the page contains a series of images that are simply labelled Foie Gras Production. The pictures elicit reactions of disgust. Each focuses either on rows of tightly packed ducks in metal cages or close-ups of the birds covered in a yellowish, sloppy substance that we assume to be the food they are force-fed. One image shows a dumpster, filled with birds that appear dead. At first, the images stood alone. Only later as I moved my cursor over the series of photographs, did I realize there were accompanying notes to each of them. Since my initial engagement with the photographs occurred in the absence of explanatory text, I thought of the possibility for these images to function alone as arguments.
Even without immediate verbal context, a general knowledge of poultry farming practices would be sufficient for a viewer to realize that the pictures condemn the particular treatment of the ducks that they display. Therefore the pictures advance a claim. Further, the reasons for the condemnation are embedded in the injury, neglect and lack of cleanliness that are captured in the images. In this instance, I believe the visual accomplishes the role of the argument. Although, it's primary line of attack is emotional - that is, the photos are designed to evoke disgust, pity, and anger - I propose that the emotion arises out of a cognitive recognition of the argumentative elements - namely, the evidence supporting the claim. In fact, at this point, I am even prompted to suggest, that most argument works eventually in an emotional realm, whether that emotion be anger against insjustice, fear of an outcome, compassion for another or even the satisfaction of feeling righteously and logically convinced. Verbal arguments reach that emotional crux in a more circuitous and elaborate way. Visual arguments act upon us more quickly. To be realistic, the role of visual arguments is limited by their very expeditiousness. They are restricted by the sheer amount of information they can convey. And therefore, I accept they are still adjunct to verbal messages.
Wednesday, November 10, 2010
Language and argument
Many of our class readings have tended to treat argument as something other than a linguistic phenomenon. They have pointed in the direction of logical elements reduced from language. That is, they have focused on argument structure - or the reaons-conclusion pairing. Even, Van Eemeren, Grootendorst and Henkemans (1996) who expand our conception of argument to include linguistic elements, focus primarily on extracting speech acts from spoken/written argument discourse. So far, it seems like Perelman and Olbrechts-Tyteca stand alone in considering linguistic features such as metaphor among the worthy components of argumentation study.
Perhaps, because I am more fascinated with naturally occurring argument discourse than with ideal, normative models, I feel compelled to consider the role of language in argumentation. In doing so, I am aware that I come dangerously close to conflating the rhetorical with the argumentative. I believe in features that distinguish argumentation from other rhetorical endeavors, but I feel reluctant to deny the rhetorical features of argumentative discourse.
To explain, I will consider the case of a definitional metaphor in food access discourse - the notion of the Food Desert. The term is applied to "neighborhoods and communities that have limited access to affordable and nutritious foods." Many of these tend to be low-income urban neighborhoods. In 2009, the USDA published a report that aimed at understanding Food Deserts and their consequences. I am surprised and disturbed by one feature of this report - namely, the way in which it presents the causes for this phenonmenon. First, the report gives primary importance to descriptive neighborhood characteristics such as race, income and road connectivity among others, in explaining the presence of a food desert. I believe this approach is consistent with the very use of the metaphor Food Desert. We typically think of a desert as a natural phenomenon, something that appears gradually, due to climatic and geological changes. The problem with adopting this metaphor is that it allows us to think of food deserts as natural to neighborhoods with certain characteristics. Consequently, it obscures an agent in the creation of food deserts. What if we determined the food desert problem a little differently, by focusing on grocery store chains that either ignore or abandon certain neighborhoods?
The topic of ecnomic explanations for grocery store locations appears in the later part of the report, almost as if it is not central to the cause of food deserts. The economic explanation is frustratingly opaque. I fully grant that economic analyses are complex because economic realities are, but the economic evidence for why grocery store chains do not enter certain neighborhoods is certainly not clear. For example, rent prices should be typically lower in these neighborhoods, lowering fixed costs. The report counters this benefit with the possibility, it may be offset by greater costs of dealing with zoning regulations and security measures. But the report offers no evidence that this may indeed be the case. Linguistically, the economic anlaysis confers agency to the market - that is, demand and supply interactions account for the store locations, obscuring the agency of corporate decision-makers.
I feel there is more we need to articulate about the causes of food deserts and there is scope for this debate to draw on language that implicates social agency, rather than using the term "desert" to focus on structural factors related to the lack of nutritional food access. I wonder how terms such as " neglected food areas", or "underserved neighborhoods" may shift the arguments in this debate and ultimate the redressal policies pursued.
Perhaps, because I am more fascinated with naturally occurring argument discourse than with ideal, normative models, I feel compelled to consider the role of language in argumentation. In doing so, I am aware that I come dangerously close to conflating the rhetorical with the argumentative. I believe in features that distinguish argumentation from other rhetorical endeavors, but I feel reluctant to deny the rhetorical features of argumentative discourse.
To explain, I will consider the case of a definitional metaphor in food access discourse - the notion of the Food Desert. The term is applied to "neighborhoods and communities that have limited access to affordable and nutritious foods." Many of these tend to be low-income urban neighborhoods. In 2009, the USDA published a report that aimed at understanding Food Deserts and their consequences. I am surprised and disturbed by one feature of this report - namely, the way in which it presents the causes for this phenonmenon. First, the report gives primary importance to descriptive neighborhood characteristics such as race, income and road connectivity among others, in explaining the presence of a food desert. I believe this approach is consistent with the very use of the metaphor Food Desert. We typically think of a desert as a natural phenomenon, something that appears gradually, due to climatic and geological changes. The problem with adopting this metaphor is that it allows us to think of food deserts as natural to neighborhoods with certain characteristics. Consequently, it obscures an agent in the creation of food deserts. What if we determined the food desert problem a little differently, by focusing on grocery store chains that either ignore or abandon certain neighborhoods?
The topic of ecnomic explanations for grocery store locations appears in the later part of the report, almost as if it is not central to the cause of food deserts. The economic explanation is frustratingly opaque. I fully grant that economic analyses are complex because economic realities are, but the economic evidence for why grocery store chains do not enter certain neighborhoods is certainly not clear. For example, rent prices should be typically lower in these neighborhoods, lowering fixed costs. The report counters this benefit with the possibility, it may be offset by greater costs of dealing with zoning regulations and security measures. But the report offers no evidence that this may indeed be the case. Linguistically, the economic anlaysis confers agency to the market - that is, demand and supply interactions account for the store locations, obscuring the agency of corporate decision-makers.
I feel there is more we need to articulate about the causes of food deserts and there is scope for this debate to draw on language that implicates social agency, rather than using the term "desert" to focus on structural factors related to the lack of nutritional food access. I wonder how terms such as " neglected food areas", or "underserved neighborhoods" may shift the arguments in this debate and ultimate the redressal policies pursued.
Wednesday, October 27, 2010
Performative argument
I have been intrigued for a while with performance as a model for understanding social action. We have been studying argument primarily as a discursive (symbolic) phenomenon. However an article I came across this past week made me consider the possibility of the performative argument.
Chris Voight, head of the Washington State Potato Commission challenged himself to a 60 day potato-only diet because he wanted to argue against the "junk food" reputation that has maligned this humble tuber. The Medical Insitute recently recommended that parents enrolled in the federally sponsored Womens, Infants and Children program should be banned from buying potatoes, in order to encourage them to include other vegetables in their family diets. The Insitute also recommended lowering the quanitity of potatoes served in federally sponsored school lunches.
Voight believes the potato is unfairly slighted and insists that it is a rich source of nutrients like potassium, fibre, vitamin C and protein. His diet that began on October 1 consists entirely of 20 potatoes a day for 60 days and nothing but potatoes. In Voight's words, "I wanted to do something bold, send a message to the people out there that the potato is so healthy you could literally live off of it for an extended period of time without impacting your health." Although Voight acknowledges this as an attention stunt, I believe his diet functions as more than an attention-getting pecursor to his argument. Infact his daily diet performs his argument. Voight's extension of the argument beyond the discursive realm capitalizes on our tendency to believe what we see, more strongly than what are told.
Interestingly, a month into his diet, Voight is now wishing he had take on a 30 day rather than a 60 day challenge. He confesses he is sick of eating potatoes and is craving other foods so much, he recently ate a potato dipped in pickle juice. Reports about his less than perfect performance are missing an important point however. Voight's initial indignation about the concern over excess potato consumption ignores the economic inequities that force many families to rely on this inexpensive food. Voight simply claimed the potato was healthy enough for substantial, sustained consumption. To be clear, although he received a go ahead from his own doctor, other medical voices do not concur on the effects of excessive potato consumption.
While Voight seems healthy so far, his growing distate for his monotonous diet should cause us to reflect on this same experience endured by those who have little choice about their diets. An availability of options may generate more distress when those options are taken away. Therefore Voight who can easily afford other foods may be even more pained by his boring diet than someone for whom options are not economically affordable. But this disrepancy mirrors the way we think and talk about the equitable distribution of food. It is my perception that enjoyment does not figure prominently in our discourse about food programs for the underpivileged. We limit our consideration of what they deserve to what's sufficient and what's healthy. We assume enjoyment of a meal is the privilege of those who can afford to purchase quality and variety.
Returning to the notion of the perfomative argument, Voight intended for his diet to enact his claim and demonstrate his conclusion. He may be successful in that he has not suffered a potato-related health disorder yet. But the distress he experiences from the monotony of his diet illuminates another concern he himself had not anticipated. It forces us to consider that those who have little economic choice over their diets, experience not just health risks but are denied the opportunity of relishing a variety of foods as well. I believe that it is the unique performative nature of Voight's argument that succeeds in awakening a consciousness and an empathy for those who are restricted by limited economic means to a more repetitive diet.
Chris Voight, head of the Washington State Potato Commission challenged himself to a 60 day potato-only diet because he wanted to argue against the "junk food" reputation that has maligned this humble tuber. The Medical Insitute recently recommended that parents enrolled in the federally sponsored Womens, Infants and Children program should be banned from buying potatoes, in order to encourage them to include other vegetables in their family diets. The Insitute also recommended lowering the quanitity of potatoes served in federally sponsored school lunches.
Voight believes the potato is unfairly slighted and insists that it is a rich source of nutrients like potassium, fibre, vitamin C and protein. His diet that began on October 1 consists entirely of 20 potatoes a day for 60 days and nothing but potatoes. In Voight's words, "I wanted to do something bold, send a message to the people out there that the potato is so healthy you could literally live off of it for an extended period of time without impacting your health." Although Voight acknowledges this as an attention stunt, I believe his diet functions as more than an attention-getting pecursor to his argument. Infact his daily diet performs his argument. Voight's extension of the argument beyond the discursive realm capitalizes on our tendency to believe what we see, more strongly than what are told.
Interestingly, a month into his diet, Voight is now wishing he had take on a 30 day rather than a 60 day challenge. He confesses he is sick of eating potatoes and is craving other foods so much, he recently ate a potato dipped in pickle juice. Reports about his less than perfect performance are missing an important point however. Voight's initial indignation about the concern over excess potato consumption ignores the economic inequities that force many families to rely on this inexpensive food. Voight simply claimed the potato was healthy enough for substantial, sustained consumption. To be clear, although he received a go ahead from his own doctor, other medical voices do not concur on the effects of excessive potato consumption.
While Voight seems healthy so far, his growing distate for his monotonous diet should cause us to reflect on this same experience endured by those who have little choice about their diets. An availability of options may generate more distress when those options are taken away. Therefore Voight who can easily afford other foods may be even more pained by his boring diet than someone for whom options are not economically affordable. But this disrepancy mirrors the way we think and talk about the equitable distribution of food. It is my perception that enjoyment does not figure prominently in our discourse about food programs for the underpivileged. We limit our consideration of what they deserve to what's sufficient and what's healthy. We assume enjoyment of a meal is the privilege of those who can afford to purchase quality and variety.
Returning to the notion of the perfomative argument, Voight intended for his diet to enact his claim and demonstrate his conclusion. He may be successful in that he has not suffered a potato-related health disorder yet. But the distress he experiences from the monotony of his diet illuminates another concern he himself had not anticipated. It forces us to consider that those who have little economic choice over their diets, experience not just health risks but are denied the opportunity of relishing a variety of foods as well. I believe that it is the unique performative nature of Voight's argument that succeeds in awakening a consciousness and an empathy for those who are restricted by limited economic means to a more repetitive diet.
Tuesday, October 19, 2010
Guilty by association
The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation incurred criticism a couple months ago for increasing its investments in Monsanto, the leading player in GM agricultural technology. I'd like to focus in particular on the August 25, 2010 press release issued by the Community Alliance for Global Justice, which like the Foundation, is also based in Seattle. The criticism contained in the press release makes use of the ad hominem attack, calling into question the Foundation's motives, because of its association with Monsanto. More specifically, it is an example of circumstantial ad hominem, exposing a discrepancy between the Foundation's professed values and its decision to support a company with a controversial track record. The press release cites a 2007 LA Times article that accused the Foundation of investing nearly 41% of its assets in companies that contradicted its philosophy for charity and social justice.
The Community Alliance press release raises concern over Monsanto's role in promoting industrial agriculture in Africa, a venture that may be profitable to a private company, but which the Community Alliance argues, could prove disastrous to the small-scale farmer in Africa. The document builds its case against Monsanto through two major allegations - a 2009 failure of its GM maize to produce crop, affecting hundres of farmers and its lawsuits against farmers for patent violation. In addition, the press release cites a World Bank and UN sponsored report that argues against the industrial agriculture model and in favor of small-scale agroecological farming for thirld world countries. Thus we see a convergence of two lines of argument -Monsanto's dubious record of social responsibility and the inappropriateness of its industrial agricultural model for the African context, both of which interact to underscore the undesirability of Monsanto as an investment option for the Gates' Foundation.
The lack of finality in argumentative proof and its vulnerability to varied interpretation is evident in the Foundation's response. Mark Suzman, director of the global development program at the Foundation, posted a response in the comments section of an online article regarding the criticism. He weakened the accusation by calling it overly simplistic and defended the Foundation's decision to invest in GM technologies arguing that the Foundation views such technologies as a means to help the small-scale farmer combat the vagaries of nature more efficiently than with conventional breeding methods.
Suzman's response seeks to diminish the scope of the Foundation's relationship with Monsanto, in direct contrast with the Community Alliance's press release which amplified the connection between the two. His rebuttal emphasizes that the Foundation's investment in GM technologies amounts to only 6% of its investment in agricultural and nutritional projects. Suzman mentions Monsanto only once, towards the end of his post and only to say that Monsanto is donating expertise to just one out of the 268 agricultural and nutritional grants that the Foundation supports. To combat the ad hominem attack, Suzman takes care to identify the Foundation's association with a wide variety of partners including farmers' groups, national research organizations and non-profits. Suzman does mention private companies, but relegates them to last position in the list of the Foundation's partnerships.
The Community Alliance press release raises concern over Monsanto's role in promoting industrial agriculture in Africa, a venture that may be profitable to a private company, but which the Community Alliance argues, could prove disastrous to the small-scale farmer in Africa. The document builds its case against Monsanto through two major allegations - a 2009 failure of its GM maize to produce crop, affecting hundres of farmers and its lawsuits against farmers for patent violation. In addition, the press release cites a World Bank and UN sponsored report that argues against the industrial agriculture model and in favor of small-scale agroecological farming for thirld world countries. Thus we see a convergence of two lines of argument -Monsanto's dubious record of social responsibility and the inappropriateness of its industrial agricultural model for the African context, both of which interact to underscore the undesirability of Monsanto as an investment option for the Gates' Foundation.
The lack of finality in argumentative proof and its vulnerability to varied interpretation is evident in the Foundation's response. Mark Suzman, director of the global development program at the Foundation, posted a response in the comments section of an online article regarding the criticism. He weakened the accusation by calling it overly simplistic and defended the Foundation's decision to invest in GM technologies arguing that the Foundation views such technologies as a means to help the small-scale farmer combat the vagaries of nature more efficiently than with conventional breeding methods.
Suzman's response seeks to diminish the scope of the Foundation's relationship with Monsanto, in direct contrast with the Community Alliance's press release which amplified the connection between the two. His rebuttal emphasizes that the Foundation's investment in GM technologies amounts to only 6% of its investment in agricultural and nutritional projects. Suzman mentions Monsanto only once, towards the end of his post and only to say that Monsanto is donating expertise to just one out of the 268 agricultural and nutritional grants that the Foundation supports. To combat the ad hominem attack, Suzman takes care to identify the Foundation's association with a wide variety of partners including farmers' groups, national research organizations and non-profits. Suzman does mention private companies, but relegates them to last position in the list of the Foundation's partnerships.
Sunday, October 17, 2010
All in the mind
This week I came across an academic article published in 2002, entitled: "Mad cows, mad corn and mad communities: the role of socio-cultural factors in the perceived risk of genetically modified food." The author Melissa L. Finucane argues for the treatment of risk as subjective rather than objective. The notion of subjective risk is a remarkable discovery for me in my attempts to understand the GM foods discourse. I had expected that the arguments on either side of the debate would converge on the topic of risk, but I had not anticipated discrepant interpretations of very idea of risk itself.
Finucane observes that technical communities traditonally view risk as objective, best assessed by groups of experts in rigorous scientific studies. Social scientists on the other hand dissociate risk into objective and subjective risk and claim in fact, that risk is inherently subjective - it cannot be measured independently of minds, which themselves are situated in cultures. Finucane provides examples of the variation in anti-GM discourse, across different cultures. For example, French resistance to GM imports from the U.S. reflects a reassertion of "culinary sovereignty" against the invasion of American food culture. Developing nations however experience the issue of GM food differently. They must balance the benefits of GM foods in terms of greater accessibility, against health and environmental risks. The fear of these risks is particularly heightened because the lack of stringent policy in these countries could tempt multinational GM food companies to test products in their markets.
Finucane also differentiates between hierarchical and egalitarian world views and provides some support for a difference in attitudes towards GM food risks, between individuals who ascribe to one or the other. A study by Sheehy et al (1996) suggests that those who are comfortable with a hierarchial world view are content to leave risk assessment to experts and make personal decisions based on expert testimony. In contrast, those with a more egalitarian world view prefer having access to the risk information themselves and the ability to make choices by comparing that information with personal beliefs.
Finucane's article brought the discursive field around GM foods into sharper focus for me. It fragmented the opposition to GM foods into culturally diverse groups whose perception of risk varies according to the concerns and values that matter to them. This observation corresponds with Perelman and Olbrechts-Tyteca's observations that argument fields can be complex and that the strength of arguments within a field is determined by the relevant audiences and the propositions they are willing to accept.
Finucane observes that technical communities traditonally view risk as objective, best assessed by groups of experts in rigorous scientific studies. Social scientists on the other hand dissociate risk into objective and subjective risk and claim in fact, that risk is inherently subjective - it cannot be measured independently of minds, which themselves are situated in cultures. Finucane provides examples of the variation in anti-GM discourse, across different cultures. For example, French resistance to GM imports from the U.S. reflects a reassertion of "culinary sovereignty" against the invasion of American food culture. Developing nations however experience the issue of GM food differently. They must balance the benefits of GM foods in terms of greater accessibility, against health and environmental risks. The fear of these risks is particularly heightened because the lack of stringent policy in these countries could tempt multinational GM food companies to test products in their markets.
Finucane also differentiates between hierarchical and egalitarian world views and provides some support for a difference in attitudes towards GM food risks, between individuals who ascribe to one or the other. A study by Sheehy et al (1996) suggests that those who are comfortable with a hierarchial world view are content to leave risk assessment to experts and make personal decisions based on expert testimony. In contrast, those with a more egalitarian world view prefer having access to the risk information themselves and the ability to make choices by comparing that information with personal beliefs.
Finucane's article brought the discursive field around GM foods into sharper focus for me. It fragmented the opposition to GM foods into culturally diverse groups whose perception of risk varies according to the concerns and values that matter to them. This observation corresponds with Perelman and Olbrechts-Tyteca's observations that argument fields can be complex and that the strength of arguments within a field is determined by the relevant audiences and the propositions they are willing to accept.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)