This week I came across an academic article published in 2002, entitled: "Mad cows, mad corn and mad communities: the role of socio-cultural factors in the perceived risk of genetically modified food." The author Melissa L. Finucane argues for the treatment of risk as subjective rather than objective. The notion of subjective risk is a remarkable discovery for me in my attempts to understand the GM foods discourse. I had expected that the arguments on either side of the debate would converge on the topic of risk, but I had not anticipated discrepant interpretations of very idea of risk itself.
Finucane observes that technical communities traditonally view risk as objective, best assessed by groups of experts in rigorous scientific studies. Social scientists on the other hand dissociate risk into objective and subjective risk and claim in fact, that risk is inherently subjective - it cannot be measured independently of minds, which themselves are situated in cultures. Finucane provides examples of the variation in anti-GM discourse, across different cultures. For example, French resistance to GM imports from the U.S. reflects a reassertion of "culinary sovereignty" against the invasion of American food culture. Developing nations however experience the issue of GM food differently. They must balance the benefits of GM foods in terms of greater accessibility, against health and environmental risks. The fear of these risks is particularly heightened because the lack of stringent policy in these countries could tempt multinational GM food companies to test products in their markets.
Finucane also differentiates between hierarchical and egalitarian world views and provides some support for a difference in attitudes towards GM food risks, between individuals who ascribe to one or the other. A study by Sheehy et al (1996) suggests that those who are comfortable with a hierarchial world view are content to leave risk assessment to experts and make personal decisions based on expert testimony. In contrast, those with a more egalitarian world view prefer having access to the risk information themselves and the ability to make choices by comparing that information with personal beliefs.
Finucane's article brought the discursive field around GM foods into sharper focus for me. It fragmented the opposition to GM foods into culturally diverse groups whose perception of risk varies according to the concerns and values that matter to them. This observation corresponds with Perelman and Olbrechts-Tyteca's observations that argument fields can be complex and that the strength of arguments within a field is determined by the relevant audiences and the propositions they are willing to accept.
No comments:
Post a Comment