Tuesday, November 23, 2010

A picture speaks a thousand words: are any of them argumentative?

In this entry, I would like to explore the possibility of the visual argument. After all our readings this semester, I distill the process of argumentation into the advancement of claims supported by reasons. While this goal appears to be best served discursively, if the barebones of an argument are its claims and its evidence, then theoretically, this structure may be fleshed out in a visual format as well. The problem I suppose, is that we very rarely encounter the visual exclusively, without some verbal preview, accompaniment or conclusion. All the same, I would like to venture that our highly mediated social lives are experiencing an erosion in verbal messages and a corresponding ascendancy of the visual form.
Popular magazines are one example of the disproportionate role of images. It's been a while since I have read something like the Cosmopolitan from cover to cover; but from thumbing through recent issues, I don't know if reading such magazines is a possibility anymore. Images seem to have eaten up text. And the magazines feel frustratingly like children's picture books designed for an audience that is still learning to decipher the written word. I wonder if this trend caters to the shorter attention spans we are developing due to the mediated nature of our everyday social lives. The extended verbal prose of snail mail letters has given way to email short-hand and even more cryptic text messaging conventions. I suggest that the predominance of verbally lean messages creates a need for rhetors to condense arguments into forms that will speak the most in the least amount of time. Images rise to the occasion.
In keeping with my focus on food politics, I examine the role of the visual in the wesbite http://www.nofoiegras.org/, which protests the consumption of foie gras (fattened duck liver). The supporting claim is that foie gras production is cruel to the birds. I would like to contrast two images on the wesbite, in order to distinguish the dual roles that images may perform in persuasive appeals - namely, a  more peripheral, enhancement function and a more direct, argumentative function. On the homepage, we see the site's banner which incorporates the black silhouette of a duck, enveloped in a white circle. A tiny red heart makes a striking contrast against the duck's black body. The drawing is iconic - it resembles the vulnerable bird. The peaceful white circle that wraps around the bird and its little red heart are invitations to consider it as a lovable, living creature rather than as simply a source for gourmet cuisine. But I would say this image doesn't argue. Rather, it augments, at a subconscious level the rhetorical message of the website.
On the other hand, the website's link to Photos and Videos takes us to a page with considerably less verbal text than we see on the homepage. In addition to a few video links, the page contains a series of images that are simply labelled Foie Gras Production. The pictures elicit reactions of disgust. Each focuses either on rows of tightly packed ducks in metal cages or close-ups of the birds covered in a yellowish, sloppy substance that we assume to be the food they are force-fed. One image shows a dumpster, filled with birds that appear dead. At first, the images stood alone. Only later as I moved my cursor over the series of photographs, did I realize there were accompanying notes to each of them. Since my initial engagement with the photographs occurred in the absence of explanatory text, I thought of the possibility for these images to function alone as arguments.
Even without immediate verbal context, a general knowledge of poultry farming practices would be sufficient for a viewer to realize that the pictures condemn the particular treatment of the ducks that they display. Therefore the pictures advance a claim. Further, the reasons for the condemnation are embedded in the injury, neglect and lack of  cleanliness that are captured in the images. In this instance, I believe the visual accomplishes the role of the argument. Although, it's primary line of attack is emotional - that is, the photos are designed to evoke disgust, pity, and anger - I propose that the emotion arises out of a cognitive recognition of the argumentative elements - namely, the evidence supporting the claim. In fact, at this point, I am even prompted to suggest, that most argument works eventually in an emotional realm, whether that emotion be anger against insjustice, fear of an outcome, compassion for another or even the satisfaction of feeling righteously and logically convinced. Verbal arguments reach that emotional crux in a more circuitous and elaborate way. Visual arguments act upon us more quickly. To be realistic, the role of visual arguments is limited by their very expeditiousness. They are restricted by the sheer amount of information they can convey. And therefore, I accept they are still adjunct to verbal messages.

1 comment:

  1. It's images like these that made me become a vegetarian in the first place. Shudder.

    However, I want to ask you about visual argument and push you to think further about visuals within argumentation. You say that anyone with a general knowledge of poultry farming practices would be able to understand the argument No Foie Gras is making. However, what about for those who don't have that background knowledge? Do the visual images still create an argument? Or, is this simply a question of audience?

    ReplyDelete