British philosopher Stephen Toulmin advocated a break-down of arguments into their component parts (explicit or implicit). I believe the greatest value in Toulmin's approach is its potential to identify what may not be overtly stated in an argument, allowing us to better recognize deficiencies or just peculiarities in the reasoning provided.
Here, you will find the minimal information that appears under the link "Products" on the website for the GM salmon company - AquaBounty Technologies.
Although unstated, we can recognize the main claim in the argument: viz. GM fish is advantageous.
Following Toulmin, I will now extract some of the premises from the webpage above, that comprise the argument leading up to this conclusion. I will also identify the function of these premises, i.e. whether they function as data, warrants or backing.
Working backwards then:
Claim: GM fish is advantageous because -
Premise: GM salmon reach market size twice as fast as traditional salmon (Data)
Premise: It is good to increase efficiency in salmon production (Implicit Warrant)
Premise: Fish farmers benefit economically with the greater efficiency (Explicit backing)
By laying out the line of reasoning above, we notice the unstated warrant. Combined with the backing, it highlights the exclusive target of AquaBounty's efficiency argument i.e. the fish farmer.
Additional backing could have provided information on the efficiency benefits to the growing population of fish consumers. But the webpage is silent on the food supply issue, perhaps because the website is targeted at those who would purchase the GM fish eggs - the farmers. The choice of backing then appears to be strategically specific.
I have some discomfort with applying Toulmin's model because the categorization of premises as either Claim, Data, Warrant or Backing seems somewhat arbitrary. I might have identified instead as my claim, the premise that: Fsh farmers benefit from more efficient GM fish. With that as my starting-point, I would need to establish the data, warrants and backing that lead to this "benefit" claim.
I am unsure about how to definitively separate Backing from Claim in extended argument discourse. Does the application of the model require some preliminary commitment regarding the main claims, followed by retro-fitting to identify the premises that lead to those claims? Might two Toulmin analyses of the same document yield different layouts depending on where the analysts choose to stake the main claims?
I am going to leave the Toulmin model alone for now, and shift focus away from micro-arguments to trace a more general theme underlying the arguments for and against the GM salmon. In reading various voices on both sides of the argument line, I detect an underlying motif that runs through both sets of arguments - namely, how to relate to the unknown. Below are comments from persons across the aisle on this issue:
Elliot Entis, founder and former CEO of AquaBounty: "We should not condemn or be fearful of technology. We need to use it to our advantage, test the individual products as the FDA is doing, but do not prejudge the results. In our country, we have a constitutional position that prohibits prior restraint of speech. We need to make certain that the same principle is applied to the other great hallmark of our country - scientific thought. Prior restraint of science, the banning of biotechnology and in particular "genetic engineering" is the goal of a number of groups who seek to eliminate the process itself without trying to determine how it can be positively used."
Sarah Parsons, blogger and sustainable food editor at Change.com: If you thought genetically engineered crops were scary (and let's face it, they are, hold onto your dinner plates . . . Two things worry me about GE animals: The meat's effect on human health, and how producing it may impact the environment . . . If salmon produce their own growth hormones in extreme amounts, what effect will it have on consumers?"
Elizabeth Weise, USA Today: "The elephant in the room is that this is just the first request . . . AquaBounty has put in place multiple protections for a fish that will be raised entirely outside of the United States, but sold here. How, critics ask, will FDA find funds to do sufficient oversight in Canada and Panama? And what happens when the fish is sold elsewhere? Who will be responsible for ensuring that the same standards are maintained?What unites these positions for and against GM salmon is "the unknown." What opposes them is their different approaches to what we don't know. The first is an approach of conquest through technology. The second is an approach of fear. The company founder speaks from a position of power, possessing as he does, the technology that allows exploration of new scientific territory. The voices that follow are fearful, suspicious, and angry. But they are not to be mistaken for cowardly voices that do not embrace scientific exploration. Their tentativeness and fear make sense when we realize they belong to those without access to the technology (both literally and in their ability to apprehend and critique it). They are nevertheless those who will be subject to the effects of the technology.
This type of analysis urges me towards our reading for this week from The New Rhetoric by Perelman and Olbrechts-Tyteca. In my next post, I will try to illuminate the motif of the "unknown" through their concept of "locus."
