Many of our class readings have tended to treat argument as something other than a linguistic phenomenon. They have pointed in the direction of logical elements reduced from language. That is, they have focused on argument structure - or the reaons-conclusion pairing. Even, Van Eemeren, Grootendorst and Henkemans (1996) who expand our conception of argument to include linguistic elements, focus primarily on extracting speech acts from spoken/written argument discourse. So far, it seems like Perelman and Olbrechts-Tyteca stand alone in considering linguistic features such as metaphor among the worthy components of argumentation study.
Perhaps, because I am more fascinated with naturally occurring argument discourse than with ideal, normative models, I feel compelled to consider the role of language in argumentation. In doing so, I am aware that I come dangerously close to conflating the rhetorical with the argumentative. I believe in features that distinguish argumentation from other rhetorical endeavors, but I feel reluctant to deny the rhetorical features of argumentative discourse.
To explain, I will consider the case of a definitional metaphor in food access discourse - the notion of the Food Desert. The term is applied to "neighborhoods and communities that have limited access to affordable and nutritious foods." Many of these tend to be low-income urban neighborhoods. In 2009, the USDA published a report that aimed at understanding Food Deserts and their consequences. I am surprised and disturbed by one feature of this report - namely, the way in which it presents the causes for this phenonmenon. First, the report gives primary importance to descriptive neighborhood characteristics such as race, income and road connectivity among others, in explaining the presence of a food desert. I believe this approach is consistent with the very use of the metaphor Food Desert. We typically think of a desert as a natural phenomenon, something that appears gradually, due to climatic and geological changes. The problem with adopting this metaphor is that it allows us to think of food deserts as natural to neighborhoods with certain characteristics. Consequently, it obscures an agent in the creation of food deserts. What if we determined the food desert problem a little differently, by focusing on grocery store chains that either ignore or abandon certain neighborhoods?
The topic of ecnomic explanations for grocery store locations appears in the later part of the report, almost as if it is not central to the cause of food deserts. The economic explanation is frustratingly opaque. I fully grant that economic analyses are complex because economic realities are, but the economic evidence for why grocery store chains do not enter certain neighborhoods is certainly not clear. For example, rent prices should be typically lower in these neighborhoods, lowering fixed costs. The report counters this benefit with the possibility, it may be offset by greater costs of dealing with zoning regulations and security measures. But the report offers no evidence that this may indeed be the case. Linguistically, the economic anlaysis confers agency to the market - that is, demand and supply interactions account for the store locations, obscuring the agency of corporate decision-makers.
I feel there is more we need to articulate about the causes of food deserts and there is scope for this debate to draw on language that implicates social agency, rather than using the term "desert" to focus on structural factors related to the lack of nutritional food access. I wonder how terms such as " neglected food areas", or "underserved neighborhoods" may shift the arguments in this debate and ultimate the redressal policies pursued.
No comments:
Post a Comment