The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation incurred criticism a couple months ago for increasing its investments in Monsanto, the leading player in GM agricultural technology. I'd like to focus in particular on the August 25, 2010 press release issued by the Community Alliance for Global Justice, which like the Foundation, is also based in Seattle. The criticism contained in the press release makes use of the ad hominem attack, calling into question the Foundation's motives, because of its association with Monsanto. More specifically, it is an example of circumstantial ad hominem, exposing a discrepancy between the Foundation's professed values and its decision to support a company with a controversial track record. The press release cites a 2007 LA Times article that accused the Foundation of investing nearly 41% of its assets in companies that contradicted its philosophy for charity and social justice.
The Community Alliance press release raises concern over Monsanto's role in promoting industrial agriculture in Africa, a venture that may be profitable to a private company, but which the Community Alliance argues, could prove disastrous to the small-scale farmer in Africa. The document builds its case against Monsanto through two major allegations - a 2009 failure of its GM maize to produce crop, affecting hundres of farmers and its lawsuits against farmers for patent violation. In addition, the press release cites a World Bank and UN sponsored report that argues against the industrial agriculture model and in favor of small-scale agroecological farming for thirld world countries. Thus we see a convergence of two lines of argument -Monsanto's dubious record of social responsibility and the inappropriateness of its industrial agricultural model for the African context, both of which interact to underscore the undesirability of Monsanto as an investment option for the Gates' Foundation.
The lack of finality in argumentative proof and its vulnerability to varied interpretation is evident in the Foundation's response. Mark Suzman, director of the global development program at the Foundation, posted a response in the comments section of an online article regarding the criticism. He weakened the accusation by calling it overly simplistic and defended the Foundation's decision to invest in GM technologies arguing that the Foundation views such technologies as a means to help the small-scale farmer combat the vagaries of nature more efficiently than with conventional breeding methods.
Suzman's response seeks to diminish the scope of the Foundation's relationship with Monsanto, in direct contrast with the Community Alliance's press release which amplified the connection between the two. His rebuttal emphasizes that the Foundation's investment in GM technologies amounts to only 6% of its investment in agricultural and nutritional projects. Suzman mentions Monsanto only once, towards the end of his post and only to say that Monsanto is donating expertise to just one out of the 268 agricultural and nutritional grants that the Foundation supports. To combat the ad hominem attack, Suzman takes care to identify the Foundation's association with a wide variety of partners including farmers' groups, national research organizations and non-profits. Suzman does mention private companies, but relegates them to last position in the list of the Foundation's partnerships.
No comments:
Post a Comment