I came across an interesting Newsweek essay entitled "Divided We Eat", that articulates my growing frustration with grocery shopping. I have been known to spend a couple of happy hours at a stretch in a grocery store. I especially enjoy browsing the aisles of specialty stores like the East Coast chain -Wegmans. I did not really consider the luxury of these experiences, until I moved to a less wealthy Midwest community that didn't offer high-end grocery store options. Now that I live in Milwaukee, close to a Whole Foods location, I am battling another obstacle. Having traded a full-time job for graduate school, I simply cannot afford to shop at a store like Whole Foods. What's worse, is that I have a hard time maintaining my resolution to consume more fruits and vegetables, because these items eat into my food budget so much more than processed food, even when I buy them at the more reasonable Pick n Save grocery chain.
Lisa Miller in the article, "Divided We Eat" advances the claim that food consumption has become the new marker of social class. Food has become fashion. She identifies the food snob, the health nut, and the locavore as ideal types that emerge in discourse about healthy eating. What's missing from this discourse however, is a recognition that ideal of healthy eating is simply out of reach for many with limited financial means. Miller cites Adam Drewnowski, epidemiologist at the University of Washington, who exposes a case of economic elitism in the practice of advocating the typical healthy diet of fruits, vegetables, lean meats, fish and grains; since these foods are unaffordable for the poorest Americans.
Drewnoski's observation echoes a discursive exchange I witnessed a few weeks ago. Nationally acclaimed locavore advocate Michael Pollan delivered a lecture at our campus, in which he argued strongly against eating processed foods. During the subsequent question-answer session, Pollan was asked by a college student what she could do to follow his advice on a meager food budget. Pollan didn't have much to say, except to agree that healthy food was expensive, but that she could try cooking rather than eating ready foods, for a somewhat cheaper, healthier alternative.
My own frustrations with grocery shopping and Pollan's response to the college student became crystallized as a serious problem in the arguments presented by Miller's article. I now see <healthy eating> as a possible ideograph in McGee's sense - that is a constellation of meanings that function as warrants for beliefs and behavior. The discourse of and around healthy eating is growing wider and louder. It is imposed as an ideal across populations (wealthy and not). For instance, Miller mentions a proposed New York City ban on the use of food-stamps to buy soda. Few of us can escape the shame of surviving on fast-food and snack-food diets. But the castigatory ideograph of <healthy eating> hides a significant, material imbalance. I recognize now that the shame of an unhealthy diet may be unjustifiably conferred on those who cannot afford to eat healthy.
A key characteristic of the ideograph is its abstract nature, allowing it to capture multiple connotations that approach an ideology. Although <healthy eating> is traditionally defined in terms of the food pyramid, or key nutritional components, health food advocates like Pollan are now redefining what it means to eat healthy. Pollan's lecture that I mentioned above, critiqued the obssessive calorie and nutrient regulations of current healthy diet practices and advocated instead that we return food from the realm of the laboratory to the realm of relationships - that is, to see food as something we share with others and as something through which we enact a relationship to the rest of the natural world.
Regardless of how it is defined, I believe an ideograph such as <healthy eating> while it serves to reflect and constitute an ideology, can simultaneously obscure material injustices that prevent some people from participating in that ideology. Blind to its partiality, proponents of the ideograph nevertheless use it punitively to shame those who cannot participate.
Also, the proposed sin tax on "junk" foods is another way that gets deployed as well. Again, I think that this really points to your argument that economic concerns really impact how one eats.
ReplyDeleteIt might also be interesting to combine this concept with your previous discussions of the food deserts.
I reccomend you talk to ko. She had a video in 672 on class I think it was "people like us" and is a study of class in the U.S. but it shows a community in uproar over a grocery store. The movie looks and describes foods by the classes that buy them. If you ask her though I am sure she knows the name and will let you check it out.
ReplyDeleteHope it helps