Wednesday, October 27, 2010

Performative argument

I have been intrigued for a while with performance as a model for understanding social action. We have been studying argument primarily as a discursive (symbolic) phenomenon. However an article I came across this past week made me consider the possibility of the performative argument.

Chris Voight, head of the Washington State Potato Commission challenged himself to a 60 day potato-only diet because he wanted to argue against the "junk food" reputation that has maligned this humble tuber. The Medical Insitute recently recommended that parents enrolled in the federally sponsored Womens, Infants and Children program should be banned from buying potatoes, in order to encourage them to include other vegetables in their family diets. The Insitute also recommended lowering the quanitity of potatoes served in federally sponsored school lunches.

Voight believes the potato is unfairly slighted and insists that it is a rich source of nutrients like potassium, fibre, vitamin C and protein. His diet that began on October 1 consists entirely of 20 potatoes a day for 60 days and nothing but potatoes. In Voight's words, "I wanted to do something bold, send a message to the people out there that the potato is so healthy you could literally live off of it for an extended period of time without impacting your health." Although Voight acknowledges this as an attention stunt, I believe his diet functions as more than an attention-getting pecursor to his argument. Infact his daily diet performs his argument. Voight's extension of the argument beyond the discursive realm capitalizes on our tendency to believe what we see, more strongly than what are told.

Interestingly,  a month into his diet, Voight is now wishing he had take on a 30 day rather than a 60 day challenge. He confesses he is sick of eating potatoes and is craving other foods so much, he recently ate a potato dipped in pickle juice. Reports about his less than perfect performance are missing an important point however. Voight's initial indignation about the concern over excess potato consumption ignores the economic inequities that force many families to rely on this inexpensive food. Voight simply claimed the potato was healthy enough for substantial, sustained consumption. To be clear, although he received a go ahead from his own doctor, other medical voices do not concur on the effects of excessive potato consumption.

While Voight seems healthy so far, his growing distate for his monotonous diet should cause us to reflect on this same experience endured by those who have little choice about their diets. An availability of options may generate more distress when those options are taken away. Therefore Voight who can easily afford other foods may be even more pained by his boring diet than someone for whom options are not economically affordable. But this disrepancy mirrors the way we think and talk about the equitable distribution of food. It is my perception that enjoyment does not figure prominently in our discourse about food programs for the underpivileged. We limit our consideration of what they deserve to what's sufficient and what's healthy. We assume enjoyment of a meal is the privilege of those who can afford to purchase quality and variety.

Returning to the notion of the perfomative argument, Voight intended for his diet to enact his claim and demonstrate his conclusion. He may be successful in that he has not suffered a potato-related health disorder yet. But the distress he experiences from the monotony of his diet illuminates another concern he himself had not anticipated. It forces us to consider that those who have little economic choice over their diets, experience not just health risks but are denied the opportunity of relishing a variety of foods as well. I believe that it is the unique performative nature of Voight's argument that succeeds in awakening a consciousness and an empathy for those who are restricted by limited economic means to a more repetitive diet.

2 comments:

  1. This reminds me a lot of Morgan Spurlock and his show entitled "30 days," where he performs his own arguments about social issues. Also, he did a food enactment himself in the movie, "Supersize Me." The intersection between food and performance is really interesting, and how individuals enact their own argument and become the data or backing for their claim.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for the other example...I haven't yet seen Supersize Me. I'll be looking up Morgan Spurlock.

    ReplyDelete