My observation this week draws attention to Gourmet magazine's balancing of two types of discourse on food. I regularly watch Food Network and periodically browse popular food magazines. My impression thus far is that these media approach food in a distinctly elitist way. That is, they focus on food as luxury and eating as pleasure.
So I was pleasantly suprised to see a section on Gourmet's website called Food Politics. I have often wondered about the lack of attention to food related social issues on the Food Network channel. I assumed it was because a political approach to food was inconsistent with a hedonistic one. So I browsed the current articles in the Food Politics section on http://www.gourmet.com/magazine to figure out how the website managed to resolve this apparent incompatibility. Of the articles currently on the website, four deal with sustainability, one with Genetically Engineered beets and two with social injustices (the two topics being wages for tomato farm workers in Florida and child labor on cocoa farms in Africa).
While these essays introduce social responsibility into the otherwise self-serving enterprise of cooking and enjoying especially gourmet food, they manage to do so without disrupting too much, the epicurean vibe that the rest of the website cultivates. How does this balancing act get accomplished?
For one, the majority of the food politics articles are sustainability related. Given the proliferation of sustainability discourse within gourmet circles, the notion of sustainability has managed to take on an equally elitist/gourmet tone. To eat sustainably is not necessarily incompatible with eating delectably.
Of the two social justice topics, both are distanced from the reader by their focus on industry players as choice-making agents. The article on a wage increase for tomato farm workers applauds one major tomato producer, the East Coast Growers and Packers for agreeing to the wage hike. It also mentions restaurant chains that recognize the fair trade program. The individual reader however, is not explicitly urged to make a choice regarding tomato consumption.
Similarly, the article on the child labor in the cocoa industry focuses on chocolate companies and their efforts or lack thereof, to monitor carefully the ethical practices of the farms from which they source their cocoa supply. Once again, the invidual reader is spared any direct discomfort or guilt arising from food choices.
Finally, I notice that the current section of Food Politics did not address the issue of food access, potentially the most potent guilt inducer for anyone committed to the pursuit of food as luxury. Having grown up in Mumbai, a city of dramatic contrast between rich and poor, I know shamefully well the tactic of ignoring the hungry face and the emaciated body of the street beggar, too close for comfort while I relish a tasty treat from a road-side food cart. The only way to enjoy that food is to forget, and render invisible even temporarily, the palpable presence of hunger and malnutrition.
I see the same tactic in Gourmet's treatment of Food Politics. An article on the lack of access to healthy food options or the incidence of starvation, does have the potential to kill an appetite.
My observations are restricted to the current articles on the Gourmet website. Now that I have discovered the Food Politics section, I will visit it more often to see whether it dares to further rupture the comfort, delight, and excess we indulge in as gourmet food lovers.
Mridula, I think this is very interesting and completely accurate in pointing out the information the magazine gives without encouraging a side. Do you think there is an argument being made for the action to take, simply because the articles are featured in the magazine?
ReplyDeleteI do think the magazine is trying to position itself as conscientious and socially just. However, its approach to social inequities seems indirect. Given its theme and readership, I think it is faced with the rhetorical challenge of celebrating the luxury of food without being socially irresponsible. It's great that the magazine is even featuring informative articles that do not relate to the enjoyment of food. And I think you're right in suggesting that there is an undertone to the articles that weighs on the side of social responsibility, even if the articles are not advocating specific action. I think that's why it would be interesting to see whether they feature articles on hunger and malnutrition, because those issues are most directly opposed to food as a luxury.
ReplyDelete