Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Vegetarians V. Heifer: The distinction between consequences and means to an end

Heifer International is an organization committed to addressing global hunger. The Heifer strategy is to provide livestock and training for the nutrition and livelihood of a family in need, with the understanding that the family will pass on one of its animal's offspring to another deserving household. The Heifer organization, according to its website services 125 countries and has reached out to 12 million families since its inception in 1944.

The organization draws sharp criticism from individuals and groups concerned about animal cruelty, specifically those who promote vegetarianism and veganism. The discourse of criticism against Heifer International is distinctive because it must advance beyond the usual lines of attack against meat/dairy consumption as a diet choice and address Heifer's moral commitment to serve the global poor. A wesbite called all-creatures.org features a collection of posts that condemn the Heifer Project as a misguided approach to solving global hunger.

Arguments that attack Heifer's approach need to establish sympathy for the issue of global hunger even as they reproach the use of animals to solve this problem. As one of the posts on all-creatures.org recognizes, those who oppose Heifer's mission may well be criticized for loving animals more than people. Therefore activists against animal cruelty attempt to discredit Heifer's strategy of helping the hungry poor, by arguing that this practice is more harmful than beneficial to the populations it claims to serve.

One of the specific anti-Heifer claims is that meat consumption actually contributes to gloabl hunger by usurping land that could be used to grow plant food for humans and dedicating it instead to the production of fodder for animals. George Monibot in a 2002 article entitled, "Why vegans were right all along" argues that the solution to global famine depends on a reduction in meat consumption by the wealthy. While Monibot does not address the Heifer Project specifically, his argument is echoed by those who oppose Heifer International. According to Monibot's article, livestock consume half the global supply of grain and he warns that we will soon be forced to confront an ethical choice to cultivate the world's arable land for either people or animals.

The clash between the reasoning that supports Heifer's mission and the reasoning provided in counter-Heifer discourse, functions on the basis of a rhetorical distinction identified by Perelman and Olbrechts-Tyteca -namely the contrast between consequences to a fact and means to an end. According to these argument theorists, rhetors may choose to present a causal link either as a case of act-consequence or a case of means-end. Each formulation serves to emphasize and diminish a different term within the concept-pair. That is, different assertions are made by either emphasing the "singleness of the act against the plurality of its consequences" or emphasizing the "singleness of the end against the multiplicity of the means." (p. 271, The New Rhetoric).

What is common to both the Heifer mission and anti-Heifer discourse is a concern for addressing global hunger. The Heifer mission frames the solution to global hunger as an end. The choice of animals to achieve this goal is not particularly significant to the Heifer argument. There is no rhetorical effort to justify the use of animals over other alternatives. The history section on the Heifer website refers to the organization as the legacy of a Midwest farmer. The choice of animals as gift to the hungry was simply motivated by the founder's own occupation.

On the other hand, the anti-Heifer argument frames the Heifer mission as an act-consequence pair. The act is Heifer's service to the world's hungry. But unlike Heifer's own mission which casts this service as a means to an end, anti-Heifer advocates focus on the unintended consequences of the Heifer Project. They succeed  in drawing more attention to the choice of animals as a solution because they extend the consequences of Heifer's service beyond feeding the poor and force us to take into account the impact that increased meat consumption will have, on our ability to produce grain for human consumption.

2 comments:

  1. This is very interesting! I like the "means to an end" angle. What I wonder is if the end is really the same for both sides of this debate. It seems true that the over-arching goal is to feel people and in this instance, poor people. But that's where the common ground or common "end" ends.

    That's a question of definition/terms I think. Feed = meat or feed = grain, but not both. I'll keep reading.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree Tracy. But I would also add that it is a value hierarchy of sorts. > Is is more important to feed people now? OR is it more important to worry about how they are fed?

    ReplyDelete