Tuesday, September 21, 2010

Bigger fish to fry



Source: Associated Press. Genetically modified salmon (rear) and non-genetically modified salmon (foreground), at the same age.


Salmon is one of my favorite fish foods. When cooked right, its flaky, fatty goodness is a treat under a creamy sauce or a blackened Cajun rub. I'll admit, I am usually tempted to let my eyes feast on pretty pictures of gourmet food but if I weren't writing this blog, I probably would have let the news item about genetically modified salmon, that appeared on a website I was browsing yesteday, completely slip by. The picture accompanying the article (see image above) is hardly a candidate for a gourmet magazine, but it evoked a perceptible reaction in me, that was definitely not gustatory. I think it was surprise, maybe tinged with alarm. Dare I say even mild outrage? My visceral reaction translated, might have been: What is this company doing super-sizing salmon like that? I could see dollar signs lining the poor giant salmon's belly. Turns out, it's not a bigger fish, just a fish that grows to market size more quickly.

Of course, my reaction is that of a lay person. I know nothing of food economics or biology. All I have to go on is an instinctual sense that making a faster airplane and making faster-growing salmon are not in the same league.

The controversy surrounding the engineered salmon reflects two key issues:
1) The fish if approved for sale by the U.S. FDA, will be the first genetically modified animal that makes its way to grocery stores.
2) Consumer advocates are demanding that the fish be labeled GM (genetically modified), although company representatives insist that the fish is not materially different from wild or farmed salmon, and therefore does not need to be identified as GM.
In the next post, I will identify some arguments that fuel the controversy and use Toulmin's diagram for analyzing arguments (our class reading topic for the week) to identify some of the explicit and implicit argument elements, in the discourse.

2 comments:

  1. My stomach is starting to churn.
    I am very interested to see where the argument of how the fish should be labeled will go. It seems like this is a question of definition. What constitutes "materially deficient"?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I mentioned in class, but thought i'd elaborate a bit here for you on Outdoor Life magazine. They have had several looks at the idea genetic alterations. It is an outdoors mag. and as such has looked more at impacts on the wild population in terms of impact. They do however have some of the top outdoor writers and contributors and may give you some insights. In particular a while back they probed food sources and the ties to chronic wasting disease in deer populations.
    hope it may help

    ReplyDelete